by ex-Gooserider » 15 Apr 2012, 09:49
I just had a short trial with one of those FreeWheel devices (Easter Seals has a "technology loan program" - this was the only thing they had that I could use...) I had mixed reviews on it at best... I only actually USED it for a few minutes, and did not feel any desire to own one after that...
Mounting was a bit tricky to figure out, but was pretty straightforward - in order to accommodate the various sorts of front footrests, there are three shim strips that adjust the clearance to the clamp (My chair didn't use any) a shim on the clamp itself that I had to take off, and two different rear clamp bits that fit different width platforms... Once you figured out what combination of parts to use, (and the manual is pretty helpful at starting to do this) the mounting is straightforward. Once the device is adjusted putting it on an off the chair felt clumsy to me, but probably would have gotten much easier with practice...
Because the device puts a lot of extra torque on the footplate, if you have a clamp on plate like I do, it is necessary to get it adjusted just right and then "pin" it in place (no more adjusting) to keep it from twisting in use.
Build quality on the device was very mixed... The clamp and arm parts were nicely machined and welded, but a lot of the clamp parts appeared to be raw aluminium, not anodised or painted. The exterior looked like it had a decent powder coat. The wheel itself was TERRIBLE - looked like it was sourced from the same place that they get kids tricycle wheels - the sort where you want the kid to burn lots of energy w/o going all that far or fast... There was a lot of easily felt play in the wheel bearings, both radial and axial... Spinning the wheel resulted in audible clicking that could also be felt in the arm. The spokes didn't look like they were mounted at a uniform angle, and the rim was not dimpled at the spoke heads. When spinning the tire, I could also see about 1/8" of side to side wobble and about 1/16" of up and down.... However if it weren't for the wheel I'd have given reasonable to good marks on build quality.
In use, I found that it seemed to help, but only in a relatively minor way, and had it's own very disconcerting handling properties... Pushing was slightly easier on all surfaces but the narrow solids on my drive wheels still didn't deal well with our lawn or the rough pavement on our street. I suspect that off-road tires would have helped, but not all that much - IOW, it would still be a lot of work to get across rough surfaces....
Handling was strange... The wheel has a lot of caster to it, but can spin 360* with an adjustable detent when the wheel is pointed straight forwards or backwards. You mount the unit with the wheel forwards, which effectively lifts it a little so that the mounted unit's wheel just barely touches the ground, and the chair is supported on the front casters. You then push forwards and slightly to one side to make the wheel spin around to the "normal" position which lifts the front of the chair and puts the weight on the Freewheel. It is then very easy to go straight as the wheel self-centers in a straight ahead position. On a smooth surface it is almost possible to go straight ahead while only stroking one wheel! Turning a small amount is fairly easy (though much harder than in stock trim), but a bit odd feeling as the turn lifts the front of the chair slightly... However turning more than a slight amount causes the wheel to go past the "balance point" where it shifts between wanting to point forwards and point backwards. As the wheel "falls" into one position or the other it puts a lot of side force on the front of the chair, pushing it either sideways or back towards center. Especially if falling sideways, it pushes hard enough that there is a range where it is difficult to steer in that direction without ending up pointing to far one way or the other...
Reversing while "on" the wheel is possible for very short distances, but you are having to fight to keep the chair balanced on the wheel, so it's difficult as the wheel will snap to the other position given the slightest amount of side excuse, again pushing the chair to one side in doing so...
Bottom line is that the Freewheel made the chair easier to push in a straight ahead line, but at a cost of making the steering very much harder and less predictable.... I did not feel any desire to own one after trying it...
ex-Gooserider