by Burgerman » 19 Nov 2024, 11:41
For those interested in what a genuine cell looks like.
Basically it is super clean, totally flat, no dings, dents, no oxidation, genuine etched qr code that can be cross referenced with the manufacturer and a spec sheet for that specific cell downloaded, and supplied by a genuine company with all the correct paperwork to garantee authenticity.
These cells are common. Or were for years. They can be found sold as "A grade" all over the place, such as chinese auction sites. But they are definitely not!
Some are re-covered, have new QR codes made up and attached, and are actually used, returned as faulty, very old stock, B grade meaning they were sold cheap as the manufacturers spec wasnt reached or that they have any of the following issues. Rapid self discharge rates, inconsistent (unmatched or high IR or impedance) low capacity*, etc.
According to Amy at docan, who sold me my cells, there are very few genuine EV grade cells sold as thee are usually for manufacturers, bulk buyers in the OEM industry etc. The rest are sold as B grade, or A grade which are both not as good.
Some B grade ones, are sold as lower capacity cells. So not the expected "230Ah" that the 55 x 200 x 173mm standard case size would be expected to be. So sold as 200, 210, 215, etc.
SOME A grade can reach the 230Ah expected. And are sold as A grade. These are not EV rated.
SOME sold as A / EV grade are actually really EV rated ones that generally have lower impedance, and are generally higher capacity than the rated 230Ah. In my case these cells are all supposed to reach 245Ah according to the last batch of over 1k cells. I tested just 1 so far. It was 245Ah. And EV rated cells are very closely matched in impedance, self disharge rates, capacity etc. So these are as good as it gets. These can cope with a hard life, in an EV and are the kind of cells that would stay in balance long term even with a typical crappy BMS over a long periods. Ask Docans Amy for EV rated cells...
- Attachments
-

- Flat. Test with a straight edge and look at the reflection. Should look like a non distorted mirror.
-

- QR code should work, be correct, and be cross reerenced to download a real spec for that specific cell.
-

- Terminals should be pristine, accurate, laser welded by machine, no scratches, clean threads, no oxidation, and look NEW!
-

- Covering should be perfectly done. But some old cells can be recovered. So check cell is completely flat. Labels can easily be added! Means nothing. And the watt hours isnt accurate as these are actually 245Ah! So its actually 782Wh.