|
Sadly this is as good as it gets with
"conventional" industry powerchair control system. And I cannot use
either of these two
hi-end systems for the following reasons:
- My latest chair
uses a
LITHIUM battery.
With ENORMOUS benefits! Voltage differences though, mean MOBILITY CONTROLLERS ARE NOT COMPATIBLE.
They are all living in yesteryear. The rest of the world has moved on but
not the mobility industry. For increased efficiency, less heat problems, and
greater speed I also use 45 Volts! This has huge advantages over 24v systems
and means HUGE compatibility issues.
Torque.
All mobility controllers lack the AMP capability. That is, their BIGGEST
controllers are just 120 Amps, and only for a few seconds... To give adequate torque
with higher geared motors needed for sensible speed, (such as the 8.5 MPH motors as I wish to use)
we need more Amps than this. As demonstrated well by the lack of torque the
faster mobility products have now. But the "Mobility Controller"
manufacturers are again stuck in yesteryear here too!
No lithium compatibility, no higher voltage
compatibility and inadequate Amp (power) capability.
So doing some basic maths tells me that to EQUAL the torque of a
GOOD 6 MPH powerchair, with 8.5 MPH version will require about
1/3rd MORE Amps than the best mobility controllers can supply.
The ROBOTEQ
controller is not INTENDED for powerchair use. BUT it can give 150
amps per motor, 250 Amps per motor peak! That's a HUGE improvement!
MUCH better than any mobility controller as far as power/torque
is concerned. And just in case
the motor impedance isn't high enough to actually draw that huge current, the available
voltage on my BM3 lithium powerchair is almost doubled at 45 Volts! So torque levels will be quite astounding and
will need to be limited to sensible levels in programming to protect motors
and make it controllable. But it will not be lacking power!
- Power (maximum
watts). Existing 24v lead (Gel) batteries cannot supply more power than the
current crop of powerchair motors and controllers demand anyway. 2x 120 amps
is a step too far for gel powerchair batteries as it is. The voltage drops
off really fast under that kind of load.
So more
power wouldn't really help much. But with a big lithium battery with 3000 Watt
Hours of stored power, with ultra low internal resistance, more power is a
great idea! BM3's huge lithium battery not only stores 3x the energy,
it can give out its power MUCH FASTER when required to do so.
So that's 45v & 150 Amp per channel = 13,500 Watts of available power for
hills, sand, snow, etc. (Compared to just 5760 watts or 120 amps and 24v from the BEST mobility
controllers). So the RoboteQ & Lithium battery system is around 2.5x as powerful as the BEST
POSSIBLE mobility
systems. It means cruising along at 15 mph will barely tax it, no heat
issues, or power issues on hills etc.
- Lower resistance (32
Mosfet power output devices!) This means greater efficiency and half the heat problems
under severe conditions.
- DISADVANTAGE (There's
always a downside!) is that the RoboteQ was never intended to be used in a mobility device. It has masses of
features, data logging capability, PC connectivity & programmability, and
full Radio Control capability built in. But it lacks the super safe
error checking etc of "safe" mobility controllers. If you use one of these in a powerchair you better
understand what this means! And its NOT plug and play. You need to build
your own joystick and control interface etc. See below. Any errors, or
problems could have this drive you under a train, or into a road... I intend
to fit a "red button" to kill all power in the event of any issues.

Top first, then left to
right... My home built joystick pod, using an APEM hall effect joystick
and 4 push buttons for RC mode,
off/on, speed reduction to "normal" levels. 45V in 12v out inverter for 12v
power for motor brakes, lights etc.
The Roboteq controller. The RC receiver in a waterproof plastic box. Note the
huge cables, and Anderson connectors used!
300 Amps total output
That's over 13,500 watts, or approx 18 Horsepower electrical output. Less "at
the wheels" obviously as motors are not 100 percent efficient. That's
about 2.5x MORE POWER than any other powerchair!
And its needed. Most mobility products do
not have enough power for safe control or steering in "difficult" situations
even at the slow speeds they are capable of.
This RoboteQ controller was never originally
designed as a powerchair controller. It lacks some of the fine tuning
(programming) capability and the continual safety checking of a "real"
super safe powerchair controller such as those supplied by PG Controls, Dynamic etc as used
in the powerchair industry.
Full Details PDF
and
Manufacturer site here.
But for those of us who are mighty sick of the safety
Nazi attitude of the "industry", lack of power or torque in existing slow
products, or lack of different voltage capability,
then Roboteq Controllers offer a real high power solution. They are
not however a simple plug and play option. Don't just buy one expecting to plug
in and use it! Its complex, involved, requires electrical and programming
understanding.
And some risk from unknown failure modes will remain. For e.g.
if a connection or input signal fails or an output transistor (Mosfet) fails in the "on"
(shorted) condition the powerchair will simply go! Back, left or
right, forwards and it would not stop without some intervention. That is a worry
if you are near traffic, or in a busy public bar or a railway station for e.g.
But many simple steps can be made to minimise this risk. And an
emergency "kill" button can be added just in case things go wrong. As I will be doing.
What we really need of course is a 150 Amp per side, 50v real
powerchair controller, made by a big manufacturer that is Lithium battery
compatible. And they are so slow in developing anything in the mobility industry
that I don't expect to see this happen in the next 5 to 10 years. So if you want
a decent powerchair today then you have to use this DIY approach. Its still
safe, controllable, as long as you have a very great understanding of what is
happening under you! If you need to get "others" to do any of this stuff for
you, then you had better look at a different system...

Here is the HDC2450 controller sat on my bed.
Because its about CONTROL and POWER!
I build and modify my own powerchairs
since if you want any real speed, and who doesn't? Control, or indoor/outdoor capability there
simply isn't any choice. See the BM1, BM2, and the other BM3 pages for design
details.
By increasing the VOLTAGE to around 45 volts
it means any given powerchair or motor motor is capable of almost double the
speed than it would do on the usual 24v.
So by using conventional HI-END 4 pole powerchair motor speeds
can be hugely increased. Since the least stressful time on any motor is while
"free running" this isn't particularly stressful! A motor draws the least power
while free running, or while going fast in straight lines in a powerchair.
A typical 6 MPH powerchair motor will do
12 mph on 48v Buy we have around 45v (Actually 42.something nominal,
and about 43v for most of the batteries useful charge.) So a 6 MPH motor will do
about 10.5 mph. And an 8.5 Mph motor from a "Groove" powerchair will do 15
MPH. This is what I am using.
And importantly the Roboteq offers a true 150 Amps per channel
with a short term peak of 250 Amps per side or 300 (500 peak) Amps total... That's approx
2.5x the power of any mobility device. It is very low resistance and uses
huge power cables for greater efficiency too. That 150 Amps peer channel @ 45v
means much more torque available on any given motor.
In addition it allows 3 different inputs to be directly used. I
had to build a special interface
for a "mobility controller" to allow me to use Radio Control to drive my
spare powerchairs about. The Roboteq allows you to plug a RC receiver in
directly. It also allows you to program, reprogram, and store your settings
directly on a PC. It also allows you to connect a laptop and log, graph,
store everything from battery voltages and amps, to controller temperatures,
input values etc as you drive. Very very flexible indeed! I can graph and log
the performance of my lithium
batteries as I drive.
But
it does mean making your own joystick "pod" using either an inductive,
hall effect, or other joystick.
This can have a frequency, or DC voltage swing, digital
duty cycle output. All are catered for the choice is yours! I will use a simple voltage swing device as used on almost every
conventional powerchair. The joystick I ordered is an APEM hall effect APEM - 3140RQ0124 - 2 AXES From RS Components, or Farnells
online.
PDF - Full Joystick Data
Opposite >>>

Blue Roboteq and my 8.5 mph motors (that will soon be running on 42v to 47v all
have the new Anderson connectors fitted and ready! Note the huge and doubled up
battery cables on the RoboteQ!
These are needed for the possible 500 Amp peak current! The motors run great on
36v and 48v. They just spin at double the speed! Quietly. So I don't expect any
motor problems.

Close up, motor and brake connectors. Added to the Groove 8.5 mph motors.
So now everything plugs together neatly and the awful weedy
standard connectors fitted to the Groove motors have been cut off and thrown
away. These Anderson connectors are MUCH more robust and unlike the ones I
removed will not burn or melt... Notice the small blue gold plated brake
connectors too. I have yet to work out how to get the Roboteq
controller to operate these... But it is possible!
On the groove motors this is
12v Don't use 24, or 36 as smoke will appear. Each brake takes 0.7 Amp (1.4A
total) at 12v measured.

This is a cheap 10 amp inverter. My batteries are between 40 and 50 volts.
But I need a 12v supply for lights, and for motor brakes. The brake on each
motor needs 0.7 Amps of power at 12v. The Inverter above has a 30v to 60v input
range. Its output is an efficient smoothed 12v output. (11.78v measured). The
Roboteq can switch this 12v on and off to work the brakes on the motors just
like a mobility controller does automatically. RED is Battery voltage in. BLACK
is ground. YELLOW is 12v out. Easy eh?
This plain black box is my Radio Control Receiver.
It needs to be protected from water. It plugs permanently the RoboteQ
controller, and operates anytime I turn on the matching
RC Transmitter.
All my powerchairs are RC capable as it makes moving them about for
cleaning and loading into vehicles etc easy. The OTHER thing is my home
built joystick pod. I hate the latest fashion of having a huge great pod, with
TV or whatever built in! The perfect pod is waterproof, small as humanly
possible, and serves no other purpose other than lights, on/off and driving the
powerchair accurately! It contains an APM hall effect Joystick and a few
switches. These control speed (slow/fast to make it legal for the public places
etc) and lights, and power, and RC mode.

This rather heavy gauge bunch of cables is the battery wiring harness. It
uses 4x 8 gauge (10 sq mm) cables! That's huge. It connects the Lithium battery
pack to the RoboteQ 300 amp controller. No fuses or breakers are used here. This
also has a connection that goes to the Inverter for 12v supply above. It will
power the inverter via a solid state relay, turned on by the RoboteQ controller.

This is all of the above! Everything uses Anderson connectors, and seriously
heavy cables... The RoboteQ will connect to the control pod, and to a USB lead
ready to plug into any PC for control and for graphing battery, motor or
changing programming settings.

The Lithium 3000+ Watt Hour 45v battery pack! Its got 3x the power of a set
of the usual group 24 batteries!
TO BE UPDATED DURING BUILD - probably lots!! 1st April 2011
|
What's the purpose of the pages about the MK3 chair and
the earlier MK1 and MK2 chairs since I don't sell them?
To embarrass
the manufacturers into getting with the show, and doing some real development
work.
And to show other wheelchair users especially Paraplegics like me, what is
possible. As such there are others now doing the same or similar, many are
members of my
Message board.
|
BM3 INFO: BM3
Home |
BM3 Lithium battery |
BM3 15 MPH | Charging Lithium
|
Construction
detailil
|
Roboteq controller
PRINTABLE:
BM3 Summary
printable PDF
|